|
|
Post by ESP on Jun 6, 2020 22:37:31 GMT
ESP vs. LMS - Stipulation - Sliced Bread! ESP:LMS:Voting rules same as always! No voting just because you're pals ARW  Voting ends Tuesday 9th. |
|
|
|
Post by droopydropp on Jun 7, 2020 13:41:06 GMT
this is gunna be a hard one!
ESP- nice job. realistic, smooth. just thought it was a tiny bit stiff on gable's part 9/10
LMS- nice job very creative realistic and smooth. the only bad part was the clay being visible 9.25/10
vote LMS
both animations were great. this was hard to choose!
|
|
|
|
Post by arw on Jun 7, 2020 16:24:45 GMT
Esp: smooth as hell. Bryans push off could have had mayne another frame. Fall was stiff. Impact was nice, sell was minimal but effective 7/10
Lms: creative, especially for the move given. Run up was nice. Flip was nice too. Maybe 1 more table break pic would work. Sell was good. 7.5/10
Vote: (i swear on my JoMo fig its not cuz we are pals 😂) lms. Close tho. I think sell was the endgame to break a tie.
|
|
|
|
Post by carltonfan2010 on Jun 7, 2020 18:48:09 GMT
ESP: Super smooth, not missing any frames. I think the movement of the figures was good too, could've maybe used some more movement in the articulation of Gable supporting Bryan to get up the ropes but its just a little nitpicking. I also would've liked to see some more leg movement from Gable instead of his feet being placed perfectly still the whole time. I thought the reaction was good too, in this specific move I think it would've been good if you had shown him rolling over to get off his back which took all the impact. The impact of the move itself was good, but I think it could've used Gable selling it more by both of them being in the air for the landing, it's a hard skill but it really sells the fast paced nature of the move better. The flow was great, I loved the way you had Bryan bounce off the ropes, which is something not a lot of people think to do, overall the trajectory was good too, little weird having Bryan land on the bottom ring rope then go through, but it makes since considering its a smaller ring, I've done that before too.
LMS: Decently smooth, I feel like you might've missed a frame or two in Sin Cara's landing and in red trunks reaction which would've helped it look more fluid. The movement of Cara was pretty basic, would've liked to see something more from him while doing the move instead of just having his arm close but not touching red trunks. I liked that you had red trunks moving and helping Cara up, but he was still pretty stiff overall and could've used more movement. The reaction from red trunks was decent but as mentioned before would've definitely benefited from more frames. The impact of the move was decent but could've used a longer rope shake for such a big landing, I like that you had Sin Cara moving around too after the landing. The flow was probably the weakest point because I think it was a little inconsistent specifically after the landing, where it ended too quick and was too fast, could've definitely used a slower frame rate at this point.
Vote: ESP
|
|
|
|
Post by steaktheguy on Jun 8, 2020 22:41:14 GMT
ESP - Smooth, great flow, the bounce off the top rope was very realistic, good and simple. Though I would've preferred a bit more of a reaction from Gable, but that's just nit-picking.
LMS - Great spot, smooth, great reaction, but I think you could have used a few more pictures here and there, and again, just nit-picking.
This is probably the toughest match yet. Every time I make a decision, I quickly change it. I'm not even just trying to be nice and say it is super close, because it really is. I feel bad having to make a decision, because these are both amazing animations. Nearly flawless.
After a while of thinking and rewatching, I think I have finally decided on ESP. Again, both are fantastic animations. The flow and realism of ESP's was very slightly better in my opinion. Great match guys.
|
|
