|
|
Post by ESP on Jun 18, 2020 22:44:43 GMT
ESP vs. LMS vs. STG - KOTS Final
ESP:
LMS:
STG:
|
|
|
|
Post by carltonfan2010 on Jun 19, 2020 11:12:52 GMT
ESP:
- Super smooth as always, loved the flow and how you had Rollins bounce off the rope, the trajectory of the moonsault was good too
- Really liked the movement of Rollins, I think Neville could've had more expressive movement, I like that you had him roll over but he remained pretty stiff throughout
- The only proper flaw I had with the animation was the impact which was lacking as it didn't look like Rollins really hit Neville, and he instantly rolled off without Neville feeling the weight of Rollins body landing on him
LMS:
- Nice and smooth, I liked the flow but I think it could've maybe benefitted from being a bit slower in parts like Joe's reaction, also would've liked to see some more bounce off the ropes, cause there was no real give from the ropes when Rey landed on them, I think you could've improved the trajectory of the moonsault too cause Rey was in the "splash" landing position too early in the flip
- I liked Rey's movement, Joe's was decent too but I would've liked some more expression from Joe upon the landing
- The impact was good, I like that you had Rey actually land on Joe which is often hard to make look right
STG:
- Very smooth animation, had a great flow to it too, I really would've liked to see some bounce from Goldust when he first hit the ropes cause it looks like he barely touched them, the trajectory of the moonsault was very good
- I didn't mind the movement of Goldust, but I think he was in the sort of "hands up" position while landing for too long
- I liked the impact, wasn't as good as LMS' but it had a proper landing which was good, definitely missing a better reaction from Triple H who didn't sell it much
Vote: ESP
|
|
|
|
Post by rawstopmotions on Jun 20, 2020 10:14:27 GMT
ESP: Super smooth. I think becuase it was so smooth it lost a bit of the impact, and it just felt almost too consistent during the landing/sell, as it lost lots of life in my opinion. I must say this he jump and launch was flawless, very impressive. Well done. 8.5/10
LMS: I didn't like the whole half the speed FPS at the beginning, felt a bit stop-and-start-y pace wise. The twisting jump was also very abrupt. I thought the flip itself was well done, and I quite liked the whole kick up of the leg on the landing. It looked like there was solid impact. 8/10
STG: The initial jump wasn't the greatest. The initial vault up looked pretty stiff, and the jump, like LMS' was abrupt, and he didn't jump much. The actual moonsault was perfect, loved the impact and the sell by both. 8/10
My vote goes to ESP, just because of the consistency throughout the animation. Took me a while to make a decision, as this was probably the closest match-up yet in my opinion. Could've gone either way, so I don't believe that anyone's animation was more enjoyable or better, more from an animation stand-point alone, ESP's was better.
|
|
|
|
Post by droopydropp on Jun 20, 2020 14:51:18 GMT
All I have to say is this is going to be a hard one lol
ESP- this was great. Smooth, had a nice reaction, realistic 9.75/10
LMS- again very smooth, realistic, could've had a better reaction 9.5/10
STG- also smooth, nice reaction, the only flaw is boldest when he turned on the rope it looked a little to fast or just a little wierd 9/10
I thought ESP's was a tad more realistic
this was a hard move I know you guys attempted it multiple times. Hard decision to make. All of you guys did great!
|
|
|
|
Post by arw on Jun 20, 2020 17:16:36 GMT
Stg- super smooth. Lacked a bit on sell, moonsault was great, 1st springboard could use more frames, impact could use more
Esp- smooth as always, better pace than the usual imo, sell was great, impact could have been a bit more frames, flip was spot on
Lms- smooth, flip well done, impact was great, sell itself could have been more.
My vote: esp. Felt a lot more animated than ur usual ones, yet still very realistic.
|
|
|
|
Post by ESP on Jun 20, 2020 19:20:20 GMT
Stg- super smooth. Lacked a bit on sell, moonsault was great, 1st springboard could use more frames, impact could use more Esp- smooth as always, better pace than the usual imo, sell was great, impact could have been a bit more frames, flip was spot on Lms- smooth, flip well done, impact was great, sell itself could have been more. My vote: esp. Felt a lot more animated than ur usual ones, yet still very realistic. Not LMS?? As you sure?? 😉 jk |
|
|
|
Post by arw on Jun 20, 2020 20:10:05 GMT
Stg- super smooth. Lacked a bit on sell, moonsault was great, 1st springboard could use more frames, impact could use more Esp- smooth as always, better pace than the usual imo, sell was great, impact could have been a bit more frames, flip was spot on Lms- smooth, flip well done, impact was great, sell itself could have been more. My vote: esp. Felt a lot more animated than ur usual ones, yet still very realistic. Not LMS?? As you sure?? 😉 jk 😂 |
|
