|
|
Post by ESP on Jun 18, 2020 22:44:59 GMT
 ESP vs. RAWESP: RAW: Voting Ends - 22nd June |
|
lms
Part Timer
Posts: 133 
|
Post by lms on Jun 19, 2020 1:31:17 GMT
Esp- too slow imo, and the camera angle makes the animation look non dynamic and bland, I think those two things really hurt this animation, overall, it was solid as always
RAW- good joint movements throughout, but it was kind if awkward looking throughout, the fall to the ground was weird as well
Vote- RAW ( was just more enjoyable to watch with better joint movements )
|
|
|
|
Post by carltonfan2010 on Jun 19, 2020 11:27:28 GMT
ESP:
- Very smooth, good flow too, but I think the run and the move itself were a bit too slow, could've definitely used a speed up in that regard, it's a tricky move to animate in mid air but you did a good job with the trajectory
- The movement of Joe was decent, I would've liked to see him be more expressive after he landed instead of just landing and looking to the side, same with the running and the plancha itself, which were both pretty well done but I think exaggerating the movement a bit was necessary in this one
- I liked the impact and reaction from Gable (?), but normally a move like that Joe wouldn't have just laid there like he was taken out after the move, so I would've liked to see him roll over instead of holding his stomach from the fall which Gable broke anyway
RAW:
- Super smooth, but it was a bit fidgety and I think would've benefitted from you removing some of the frames that slowed it down, which also leads to that the animation could've used being sped up
- The movement was very expressive, I didn't really like how you animated the running it looked a bit unnatural, the movement in mid air was super impressive, but I think you messed the trajectory up a bit which made you have to move Randy into place to save it from being a botch
- I liked Randy's movements too but I think the super big straight feet extended kick up was a bit of an oversell, but I think Slater overselled it too in a different way considering he landed right on Orton so I don't think the landing on his belly and staying there was necessary when he probably should've rolled over and gotten half up
Vote: ESP
|
|
|
|
Post by droopydropp on Jun 20, 2020 14:55:15 GMT
ESP - nice job, a little slow w the running and a little floaty but besides that nice job 8/10
RAW- nice job, was a little floaty as well and randy trying to catch heath was a little weird as carlton said but it was also unique if that's what you were looking for 8.5/10
Another hard one, I hate voting lol
Vote: RAW
|
|
|
|
Post by arw on Jun 20, 2020 17:19:22 GMT
Esp: running didnt really lift off the floor a whole lot, tho remained smooth. Jump over ropes as well as the spiral were nicely done, impact and sell were minimal
RAW: running seemed to kinda be held back by a resistance. As if running on a treadmill, tho the movement of the running was nice. Jump over ropes into spiral was nicely done, but orton moved into the move oddly. Sell and impact were good.
Vote: RAW
|
|
