|
|
Post by ESP on Jul 16, 2020 23:00:32 GMT
  ESP vs. WrestlingKnight vs. CarltonFan vs. LLI vs. DroopyDropp ESP (C): WrestlingKnight: Carlton: LLI: Droopy: Voting rules are the same as always. Voting Ends 23rd July. |
|
|
|
Post by arw on Jul 16, 2020 23:41:26 GMT
Esp- smooth and amazing usage of angle change for the glass break. Sell was nice. Loved it.
Wkw- a bit awkward on joint movement. Smooth and decent sell
Carlton- super smooth. I feel some more to start it off would be nice. Sell was great tho
Droopy- smooth but I feel the break was a bit off
Lli- smooth but kinda stiff. Nice break
My vote: esp
|
|
|
|
Post by rawstopmotions on Jul 16, 2020 23:48:00 GMT
ESP: Good as always. The catch was a tad awkward, but for the most part, I really liked ur glass break. 7.5/10
WKW: You rly surprised me on this one, it was really good! 7.5/10
Carlton: Really good. I think that movement wise yours was the best. However the glass break was weird in that the glass disappeared. 7.5/10
LLI: I really liked the general pace of yours, it was pretty realistic. It was stiff, but it was pretty good. 7/10
Droopy: imo yours was stiff, and slow. I think had it've gotten more speed to it this would've been fixed. 7/10
Final vote: Even though I have 3 people with the same rating, I'm gonna go with Carlton. ONly just though. Somehting about the movements really impressed me. ESP and WKW it was by this much š¤!
|
|
lms
Part Timer
Posts: 133 
|
Post by lms on Jul 17, 2020 4:23:13 GMT
Esp- smooth as usual, I actually liked the speed on this one, i would've liked to maybe see a bit more of a struggle when seth gets caught, and maybe more reaction, very very solid
Wkw- kinda awkward looking, good attempt at the move, somewhatbsmooth throughout, the flow just wasnt there for me
Carlton- smooth as always, angle change was a bit odd tho, I think if you had a bit more run up to the move, my vote would go to you
Droopy- pretty choppy looking, if this was smoother it would've compared better, good attempt at this one, lighting in this is kind of an issue for you as well
Lli- as with others, needs some work with the flow and smoothness, but it's very cool to see you in this trying your best
My vote:Ā Esp, so consistent, and technically proficient, hard to beat, close second would be carlton, cool to see everyone competing
|
|
|
|
Post by dhink182 on Jul 17, 2020 19:33:31 GMT
ESP - Very smooth as always, I would've liked to see more of a struggle so to speak between Rollins and Lesnar, but that's kind of a nitpick. Very good though, and I thought the impact and flow were great. - 7/10
WKW - Fidgety but still good, more of a build up would've been nice, joint movement was good, but the flow wasn't there. It's really not bad though. - 5/10
Carlton - I felt like the little bend forward was a nice addition that not many people really think about. It was smooth and flowed well, the camera change was a bit wonky but I didn't consider it to take away from the move. I would've liked to see Brock have more movement after impact. Realistic though and that's what works for me. - 7.5/10
Lli - Very stiff and little movements, as well as lots of string and shadows. It's a nice attempt, but I'd like to see you work on replicating movements better and really try to get them realistic. Consider how you would do a move like that if you were a wrestler. That will help you replicate bends and movements. - 2/10
Droppy - As with Lli, very stiff and little movement from either figure. The camera angle and lighting didn't do you any favors either. Much of what I said for Lli applies for you as well, I think it's a good attempt but really try to imagine the move as if you were doing it yourself and also watch a lot of reference videos. The table break was odd and lacking as well. - 1.5/10
Vote: Carlton
|
|
|
|
Post by WWExtreme25 on Jul 21, 2020 13:17:19 GMT
ESP: Always good to see people add build up on an animation. I've always thought it really sells into the move thats about to happen. Very smooth as always, I thought the springboard was nicely done and the camera pan was well animated. The catch could've done with a bit more exaggeration from Brock as he caught Seth (knee bends etc) but the throw and impact was very solid. It would be cool to see you get a bigger ring if you can as I've noticed you always have problems fitting the wrestlers in when you go for big throws across it. The glass break was nice it just wouldve been nicer to see a bigger reaction due to the extreme nature of the move. Solid attempt though! 8/10
WrestlingKnight: I thought on the whole the move was a bit too fidgety. I liked the well you had Kofi go into Bourne and pull him into the B2B but on the whole for me, it all sort of went by too quick and was a little fast. Appreciated the sell from bourne though! 6/10
Josh: I see you decided to compete again then! Thought on the whole a very smooth attempt - Clear to see not much rust from you at all. I thought the way Lesnar went into the move was a bit stiff as they both sort of just leant back and then the other way. If you maybe exaggerated Lesnar's knees a bit more in bending them showing him struggling to lift Hardy that wouldve looked better imo! The overall smoothness was nice though, and I loved the oversell from Hardy so good to see you back. 7.5/10
LLI: Nice to see a different take on the stip. Love that match from Angle & Shane at KOTR so was cool to see that spot animated. I think overall the mov could've done with a lot more pictures between frames in order to make the animation smoother. It was also a bit stiff in the joints and I thought that if you bent them a bit more and studied the move frame by frame on Youtube (used to help me get it right) then it would've been easier to animated in each photo. The Impact was awesome though, and I liked AJ's oversell. 5/10
Droopy: I liked the setup of this move, but I think a big factor that let it down slightly was the shadows and the lighting. The throw from Harpur was nice but it was a bit choppy in stages and needed a few more frames to smoothen it out. Table break was nice though and the reaction was cool. Just needed a few more pics and a bit more joint movements to be up there with the others. Good effort though. 5.5/10
Overall for me ESP had the best animation because it had a nice amount of build up, was consistently smooth and fluid throughout, and the animation as a whole was better to watch. I just thought it lacked more of a reaction.
VOTE: ESP
|
|
|
|
Post by WZW Animations on Jul 22, 2020 7:20:06 GMT
ESP: The long beginning frame was a bit odd. But, the springboard was executed nicely, the camera pan was smooth, the catch and build up to the belly to belly was a tad stiff (Brock's knees could've bent to prep for the toss), the throw and impact was well done. My only critique is the size of the ring and placement hurts the figures, as I noticed Seth landing on the ropes and the wall. As WWExtreme25 mentioned, would be cool for you to get a bigger ring for those tosses and other extreme spots with weapons. The glass break was done nicely, but lacked a big reaction, because Glass= Ouchie.
8/10
WKW: You are definitely improving and getting out of your comfort zone, as I've seen you challenge yourself and taking up suggestions on Discord. The whole animation was a tad fidgety. Liked that Kofi pulled Bourne into the Belly to Belly. The chairs sliding kinda bothered me, but the glass break was well done. The animation seemed to quick for me. Could've used a bit more reaction as well.
6.5/10
Carlton: Good to see you back and competing again man. Very smooth animation, throughout. Lesnar seemed a tad stiff, maybe bent his knees more in lifting Jeff. Hopefully you get a ring and poster board set up again. Hard to see the glass, after Jeff landed on it. But, doesn't decide the animation quality
8.5/10
LLI: Not everyday so I see a use for the plastic used for boxing the figures to be used this way. Also very rarely see people animate a glass break in a vertical matter, instead of horizontally laid out on chairs or etc. But, the animation lacked several frames. Maybe watch the footage you're trying to replicate to get the movements down to be more smooth. Also the camera was unsteady, recommend getting a mini tripod or something to secure your camera. Loved AJ's sell and the added blood. I've also seen string or photoshopped string during the throw. I also recommend getting a photo editor with a clone stamp tool and a blur tool.
5/10
Droopy: The shadows and the string really stood out on this one. Nice throw from Harper, but it was pretty choppy. The after math of the move was somewhat smooth. I recommend going through your pics periodically during your animation to see if the pic flows well with the previous frame. May sound tedious, but it helps maintain a healthy frame flow for an animation. The breaking of the table was ok too.
5.5/10
Final vote: Carlton
The deciding factor was the sell of the move. ESP's sell was kinda dead, while Carlton's was more exaggerated. Well done guys!
|
|
