|
|
Post by ESP on Jul 16, 2020 23:02:02 GMT
Grudge Match!
LMS:
ARW:
Voting rules are the same as always.
Voting Ends 23rd July.
|
|
|
|
Post by rawstopmotions on Jul 16, 2020 23:58:08 GMT
LMS: The speed and movement of this one was superb, and I liked the punch movement and sell. 8/10
ARW: I liked the impact. but the punch was weird. It was an awkward jump imo. But KO's sell was awesome 7.5/10
Final vote: LMS
|
|
LLI
Part Timer
Posts: 141
|
Post by LLI on Jul 17, 2020 4:16:41 GMT
LMS: great view, smooth, nice punch, and great selling by both
8.5\10
ARW: weird view, smooth, jump was a bit awkward but KO selling was good
7/10
|
|
|
|
Post by carltonfan2010 on Jul 17, 2020 9:44:54 GMT
LMS: Another super smooth animation, I liked the grey AJ's movements, but I think the black one's movements were a bit haphazardly done, I think you should've had him in the air for at least a second while landing instead of keeping his feet planted to the mat, I think also his reaction could've been a bit better instead of just landing and moving his torso/legs, I like that you had grey fell down off the impact, but it felt a bit weird how he turned around after landing and then fell, would've been more natural if he fell off the impact from landing.
ARW: I really liked the movement from Reigns in doing the punch in mid air it looked super realistic, I thought Owens movement was alright, a bit fidgety in the time he was waiting for Reigns, I like the added touch of having him push Reigns up, his reaction was good too, I like that you actually showed his head being hurt by the move, I think Reign was a bit fidgety after landing tho.
Both guys re-enacted the move pretty well, but I think ARW's reaction was better and more realistic, and the re-enactment was slightly more realistic too.
Vote: ARW
|
|
|
|
Post by ESP on Jul 17, 2020 10:31:02 GMT
LMS - liked the running and taunt at the start, shadows were really distracting, actual punch movements looked good, falling AJ’s reaction was alright, Wasn’t a fan of punching AJ falling over, decent flow throughout - 7
ARW - running looked decent but he moved to close to Owens, this caused him to jump vertically and punch which looked a bit odd, but the movements on the punch were solid, good reaction also, solid flow and mostly smooth - 7.5
Vote - ARW
Veeeery tough one for me, very little separating the two.
|
|
|
|
Post by droopydropp on Jul 17, 2020 15:18:34 GMT
LMS - nice job smooth but the only problem is here was the reaction. I thought it could have been a bit better. besides that very good 8/10
ARW- nice i like how u had owens push reigns up very creative smooth and good reaction 8.5/10
this was a hard one
but my vote is ARW
|
|
|
|
Post by dhink182 on Jul 22, 2020 1:57:50 GMT
LMS: I like this one a lot. I think attacking AJ could've used a few more frames when he turned into the ropes to bounce off, it seems jumpy. I like how you did the move itself, and the reaction. I did like how attacking AJ fell over, I like stuff like that in single animations. It makes me feel like it's a highlight from a match instead of an animation with no context for lack of a better word. - 7/10
ARW: I think this is the better animation between the two but I do also think Reigns follow through was lackluster when you think about the torque that goes into the move. And I wasn't really a fan of how KO just kind of fell back instead of turning with the punch. - 7.1/10
Vote: ARW
|
|
|
|
Post by WZW Animations on Jul 22, 2020 7:45:46 GMT
LMS: Pretty smooth beginning of the animation. The run was nice, but could've used a few more frames when turning AJ to bounce of the ropes. The punch and the sell from both guys was well done. Just need to watch the string that shows up on the ring. Otherwise, a solid animation
7.5/10
ARW: This is a nice and smooth animation, same quality as LMS's. But, it seemed that it lacked a reaction from Reigns and KO. Also Reigns just seemed to block the move from the camera shot.
7/10
Final Vote: LMS
Deciding factor was LMS had more of a build up and more of a reaction than ARW. ARW's animation seemed to be straight to the point, which ain't a bad thing either. Just the more addition to the reaction of the punch was what made me give my vote to LMS. Well done guys!
|
|
