|
|
Post by ESP on Jul 16, 2020 23:02:09 GMT
 RAW(C): ESP: Voting rules are the same as always. Voting Ends 23rd July. |
|
|
|
Post by arw on Jul 16, 2020 23:35:44 GMT
Raw: smooth flip and great struggle shown. Nice impact. Sell could be a bit more.
Esp: smooth as hell. Tombstone looked great. Liked it a lot.
Close one for me to decide but I think I'm gonna have to go esp on this one
|
|
|
|
Post by droopydropp on Jul 17, 2020 15:22:52 GMT
hard move to do
ESP- nice job smooth good reaction I just thought HBK kind of fell into taker. I thought there could have been more of Taker catching HBK. But still nice job 8/10
RAW- nice very smooth realistic. the only thing was heath reaction was a bit off. A bit unrealistic with the legs off to the sides. Maybe him just landing on his face after the tombstone would have been better. Besides that nice job 9/10
vote - RAW
|
|
|
|
Post by WWExtreme25 on Jul 17, 2020 15:55:18 GMT
Glad to see there's still a forum going with matches and titles, so I decided to join to see what the PPV's were about. I'm going to give my best vote for both!
RAW: First and foremost I have to say the joint movements in here were incredible. You really gave it your all in trying to make the figures as lifelike as possible and I loved that. From the way Slater catches punk, to the bending in the knees etc. you really nailed those joints. My only really small nitpicks on this was that the moonsault from punk couldve been sped up slightly as the hang time was a little slow for me. Also I noticed (very annoying from me I know) that slaters shadow disappeared at times under his feet, Which made it look like he wasn't grounded. Maybe it was from editing shadows which caused this but that caught my attention. The impact was amazing though due to the way punks legs bent and you really felt as though his head was driven straight through the chair. Other than that, I thought this was near perfect. 9/10
ESP: Very smooth as always, and very fluid with how the animation flowed. I thought the springboard was well done but couldve done with a bit more bend in the knees (towards Michaels'chest) as he catapulted up. The moonsault itself was really well done, but the way in which taker caught Michaels didnt have as much joint movement as RAW. The impact of the tombstone was again extremely smooth and well done but it looked as though Michaels' legs went through the ropes which had a slight unrealistic look to it. I also thought the tombstone move itself needed a bit more exaggeration on the joints to have that added impact. But the overall flow to this and smoothness on the whole was really well done as always. 8.8/10
Awesome match! I think both had very slight flaws, but the thing that's edged it for me is the constant fluidity in RAW's joints. Not many people pay too much attention to the detail of joints in the way you animated it without it being fidgety was class to see, so that's why my vote has gone to him.
VOTE: RAW
|
|
|
|
Post by dhink182 on Jul 22, 2020 1:39:25 GMT
RAW: Rob in the post above this absolutely nailed it with your animation. I honestly wish I could add more but there's no way I can articulate any more thought on this. But I just want to commend you on a great animation and I think you nailed it. - 9/10
ESP: Again, like Rob said, very smooth and fluid. I think Shawn needed more movement overall, especially in the legs on the jump. If this was against any other animation than RAW's, my vote would go to you, but your animation just lacked the realism and joint movement that I thought RAWs had. That being said, it's still incredible and I like it a lot. - 8/10
Vote: RAW
|
|
lms
Part Timer
Posts: 133 
|
Post by lms on Jul 22, 2020 2:40:57 GMT
Raw- very good joint movement throughout, though the moonsault was a bit floaty and trajectory was off, seems almost like he shouldve missed the moonsault, but the catch was amazing and the reaction was superb. Very well done
Esp- smooth as always, but was just lifeless, I think there definitely needed to be more movement and a sense of weight. Still very well done,just doesnt have that movement that RAW does so well
My vote- RAW
Well done to you both
|
|
|
|
Post by WZW Animations on Jul 22, 2020 8:00:08 GMT
Holy Shit! Let's see if I can decide on who gets my vote on this one.
RAW: Very smooth and very articulated on the joints. The trajectory seemed off and floaty. Loved the catch and the struggling from Punk and Slater. I think the Slater laying there with his knees bent like that was a little unlife like (if that makes sense). The sell did seem to be lacking.
9/10
ESP: Smooth animation and nice springboard and trajectory. Nice catch, but lacked the struggle and the sell really lacked. Not a huge fan of the last frame in different angles (just a personal taste)
8.9/10
Final vote: RAW
My deciding factor was that RAW's animation has a bit more life to it. True, his trajectory did see off and the sell could've been more. But, ESP lacked struggle after the catch to the tombstone. It was really tough to decide between two great animators and had to give my vote to RAW on one fraction of a point. That's how close it was for me. VERY WELL DONE GUYS!
|
|
LLI
Part Timer
Posts: 141
|
Post by LLI on Jul 22, 2020 13:22:07 GMT
RAW: Another Awesome animation from you my friend, as everyone before me said the tombstone looked kinda trajectory but the struggle made it look incredibly real, all the joint movements were on point, and the selling was great
9/10
ESP: It was one of your best if not your best I really liked it, this moonsault is the best Ive ever seen, tha catch could have been a bit better and also the fall was great, the selling needed a bit more.
8.7/10
the thing that made RAW, a little bit better was the struggle they had, which yours didnt have and maybe if RAW didnt did that I would have voted for you.
Great match both of you
|
|
