|
|
Post by arw on Sept 15, 2020 13:53:21 GMT
Gonna try to get as much up as i can before school
GRUDGE MATCH - R A W vs SSW vs ARW
RAW-
SSW-
ARW-
Same voting as usual. Good and bad of each animation, as well as your vote.
I'll set the voting deadline after i finish posting all matches, hopefully before school. But school is short so it shouldnt be too bad
|
|
lms
Part Timer
Posts: 133 
|
Post by lms on Sept 15, 2020 16:36:34 GMT
RAW- very smooth, good joint movement throughout, and a solid reaction, only two complaints, the person doing the move was on a paused fram for too long at the start, and the camera angle made the animation overall look more bland.
SSW- pretty choppy throughout, definitely needs more frames for each movement, and the camera angle switch made the animation hard to follow
Arw- smooth throughout, i personally, didnt like the run/jump, wouldve preferred it be more of a run then just a large step. Camera movement was nice, showing the action the whole way through. Reaction was solid, just wish it didn't end so early.
My vote- Raw, the movement and fluidity it too good, well done to you all
|
|
|
|
Post by G6W Animations on Sept 15, 2020 17:32:22 GMT
RAW- Very Smooth With Awesome Reaction As Always I Really Dont Have A Complaint besides before he fully jumps its a little slow
ARW-Another One Of Your Animations I Dont Really Have A Complaint About But I Do Think You Should Have Had A Little Bit More Of A Reaction For Seth
SSW-Its A Little Bit Slow On The Sami Part But Other Than That Its Really Really Good
My Vote Goes To RAW
|
|
|
|
Post by ESP on Sept 15, 2020 23:59:44 GMT
RAW - weird starting position and a little slow, other than that phenomenal joint movements, so dynamic, realistic, great impact, rotation looked awesome, reaction was good also. Maybe the spot could’ve been more RKO focused but that’s nitpicking. - 8/10
SSW - liked the creativity, Some smooth parts but also some choppy parts, quite stiff throughout But the stiff poses were at least accurate and looked decent, reaction wasn’t bad - 6/10
ARW - as I said on the top 5, something I really like about this, looking back tho Rollins was more stiff throughout than I remember, and the big chops between movement switches bothers me more, still great and airtime movements still look phenomenal - 7/10
Vote - RAW
Really good match guys, 3 good animations.
|
|
|
|
Post by carltonfan2010 on Sept 18, 2020 11:11:26 GMT
RAW: Super smooth, The joint movement of Punk was really good, I feel like the trajectory of Punk's jump and the mid air rotation were a bit off, which I think are the hardest parts of high flying moves like these, I liked his reaction but I think the bounce was maybe a little too high, Roderick's movement was good too, I like how you had him jump twice to get into position for the RKO, I liked his reaction to the move but I thought it was a little awkward the way he transitioned positions with his arms so far back, some little things to work on but a very good effort
SSW: It was smooth in parts but also fidgety at points too, the joint movement of Orton was lacking, he got into the RKO position too fast and just sat there in mid air versus how it happens irl where he works his way into that position, Randy's reaction was kinda weird cause you had him go from being on his side to being on his front instantly without him moving over, Zayn too was super stiff and didn't move around enough, I like that you added a bit of a reaction by him, I would've liked to have seen you make Zayn and Orton go a bit higher with more of a jump from Zayn
ARW: Very fluid, it wasn't as buttery smooth as RAW's animation but it still plays very well, I really liked Orton's movements in doing the RKO and his reaction was great too, I liked Rollin's joint movement and it looked pretty realistic but I think you could've had a more realistic climb by Rollins, he had a second jump without getting the momentum from Orton that he would've needed to go up so high, I also think you could've traced his steps better by having him take a step with his right foot then left foot and stomp with his right so it looked more natural
Vote: RAW
|
|
LLI
Part Timer
Posts: 141
|
Post by LLI on Sept 20, 2020 4:15:56 GMT
Well what can I say about it, everyone described the animations perfectly, but I still have to vote
RAW: its a phenomenal animation, the only thing I could say, is that I would have liked Strong to move more, have a better reaction, his legs were stiff, other than it was almost perfect.
SSW: it was a good animation overall, it lacked frames throughout, also the joints could have been moved more, i didnt liked the camera switches and the reaction could have more
ARW: a great animation, rollins should had made more steps before the jump, it flowed nicely and the reaction and joint movement were good, it started and ended to quickly for me but out of there it was great.
(I know i mostly said the bad parts of the animations but everyone already said everything about them)
Also I think this was a great match, and ssw yours was a great animation sadly you faced 2 of the best animators ever. Congrats to the 3 of you
Winner: RAW
|
|
|
|
Post by droopydropp on Sept 20, 2020 15:22:05 GMT
RAW- very creative and smooth just a little choppy in the beginning but still very good 9/10
SSW- again very creative, the beginning was a little choppy, I thought they could have moved a little more in the air, but still very good 7.5/10
ARW- very smooth and creative. The only thing is I think there could have been more of a reaction, still good tho 8/10
vote RAW
|
|
