|
|
Post by ESP on Apr 9, 2020 22:56:17 GMT
ARW vs. LMS - Stipulation - Frog Splash
LMS:
ARW:
To vote on a match, you must give reasons for your vote, discuss the good and the bad about all entries, then reveal your final vote. As mentioned before, this will be done on the thread for the show.
If you are online during voting, vote. Especially if you’re on the show. Don’t be a dick. We need votes to make the matches fun and competitive.
|
|
|
|
Post by ESP on Apr 9, 2020 23:20:28 GMT
LMS - really smooth, good motion, table break was good, but the quality was really poor, string was very visible and shadows were issues.
ARW - also quite smooth, but quality was also bad, and had a distracting shadow, reaction was poor, and it was quite stiff, also the camera change once again felt pointless, but the impact was good
Ive gotta go with LMS on this one.
|
|
WOWF
Part Timer
Posts: 91 
|
Post by WOWF on Apr 9, 2020 23:53:33 GMT
LMS: It was smooth, the camera down movement was a good touch and I think it had a nice impact. It was kinda stiff overall, Morrison could've had a better reaction.
ARW: Not as much smooth as LMS, the frogsplash itself felt kinda weird, and CM Punk barely had any reaction, very stiff.
MY VOTE GOES TO: LMS
|
|
|
|
Post by arkhamanimations on Apr 10, 2020 0:29:09 GMT
LMS: Really liked this! Taunt was fantastic, but the lead-in to the jump could've flowed a bit better. The jump itself looked really smooth and well animated. I especially liked the camera pan to give it some more pace, although I wish you hadn't cut as abruptly at the end as it was a really smooth pan that looked a tad jarring when the angle shifted. I thought Cara's reaction was really spot on and well done, fantastic stuff there. Morrison could've winced a bit more maybe? A rope bounce could've added to the sell as well, I think. Some minor things with the shadows at the start were also there, but I think the move had a great flow and looked really realistic. Really nice job!
ARW: Great job! The taunt looked a bit fidgety, but the movements were good. I think your angle was a bit off, it looked really cramped and the constricted framing let down the flow a bit. I think the frog splasher could've jumped a bit higher too, the movement looked good but the trajectory wasn't quite there. He moved a bit back and forth and to the side in the air as well, which let down the otherwise really good joint movements. His reaction was really clever and well-done, although some extra frames would've aided the smoothness. Like LMS, I think you could've given Punk a bit more of a reaction, but it still looked quite good. A very solid animation here from you!
VOTE: LMS takes this one as it just had a greater level of joint movement and smoothness in my eyes, although it was a good match.
|
|
|
|
Post by rawstopmotions on Apr 10, 2020 7:18:05 GMT
LMS: A great animation, good pacing, movement, and reaction.
ARw: Good pacing, and a good setup, just, in my opinion, the reaction felt to sudden. Ricochet reacted to much while CM Punk didn't.
Because of the reaction, I'm going LMS, but again, very close!
|
|
|
|
Post by steaktheguy on Apr 10, 2020 17:39:02 GMT
LMS - Jump was good, a bit fidgety though. Impact through the table was great, just not much reaction. Also very smooth.
ARW - Jump could've gone a bit higher, but the impact and reaction was okay.
My vote: LMS
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 10, 2020 22:57:34 GMT
LMS= really smooth could use more reaction but the the move itself is great and everything else.
ARW= really great too the reaction was great but like STG said it could of been better of the jump was higher but everything else it good too.
My vote is ARW
|
|
|
|
Post by droopydropp on Apr 11, 2020 4:08:57 GMT
lms - very smooth and realistic just wish for more of a reaction
arw- the splash felt kinda weird or crocked maybe. but smooth. but i give u credit u had like 10 of these to do lol
but my vote is lms
|
|
